What the Old Media Owes the New Media | Media | Chicago Reader

News & Politics » Media

What the Old Media Owes the New Media

A citizen journalist is smarting from a slight by Chicago Tonight.


Sign up for our newsletters Subscribe


Because mayors of Chicago have been known to die in office, the city has a need for a statutorily designated successor. But because the vice mayor has no duties besides waiting in the wings, his office would seem to have no need for an annual budget of more than $100,000.

But that's the budget that's allocated to the vice mayor's office, and in recent weeks, the Web site Lake Effect News has posted two long articles examining that allocation. The vice mayor is 50th Ward alderman Bernie Stone, and the March 26 story, "Another City Council Stealth Budget?" reported that his expenses as vice mayor "routinely" run some 15 to 22 percent over that budget. The beneficiaries of those expenses, it added, have included a variety of friends and relatives of other aldermen. The April 1 story, "156 Paid out of Vice Mayor's Budget," named more names, asserting what it called "a distinct pattern of considerable overlap and frequent juggling of payees between City Council accounts, including many instances of possible double, triple and even quadruple dipping." It said city documents "showed over 1,300 expenditures that were made to 156 individuals throughout the city's 50 aldermanic wards between 2006 and late 2009."

The stories, both by Hugh Devlin, were provocative but clumsily written and hard to follow. Like a lot of low-budget, new-media journalism, they could be interpreted as flares sent aloft to alert the mainstream media: "Good story possibility here—come running."

That was the effect Devlin's reporting had on at least two other journalists who read it. Patrick Boylan runs a site of his own, the Welles Park Bulldog. When he spotted the name of Monica Schulter—the daughter of his local alderman, the 47th Ward's Eugene Schulter—in the list of vice-mayoral budget beneficiaries, he called the alderman for comment. He didn't get it, but he posted a story anyway, scrupulously giving credit where it was due and linking to Devlin's original.

Aaron Stern, a paid intern serving as a producer for WTTW's Chicago Tonight, read Devlin, talked to him, and then began working up a story of his own, which aired the evening of April 13. The next morning Boylan called me. He was surprised that the WTTW report hadn't touched on Devlin's main point—that the vice mayor's money was being spread around the aldermen's families and cronies. And he was ticked that Lake Effect News had gone uncredited. Host Phil Ponce asserted in his introduction: "Chicago Tonight has found a little-known city office that has a budget and staff, but no actual ongoing duties."

"WTTW didn't find that," Boylan said. "It was Lake Effect News."

Lake Effect News is an archetypal example of hyperlocal new media launched by orphaned veterans of the MSM. Its founder, Lorraine Swanson, was the last editor of the News-Star, a Lerner weekly that changed hands more than once, and was shut down in March 2009 by Wednesday Journal Inc. sold in March 2009 by Wednesday Journal Inc. to Inside Publications. Passionate about neighborhood journalism, Swanson launched Lake Effect News, which covers the News-Star's old lakefront neighborhoods and the neighborhoods to the west that had been the domain of the Booster, another Lerner weekly abandoned by Wednesday Journal.

Writing in January about the launch of another local site, Central Square Ledger, I asked Swanson how she was doing. "I probably put like 14 hours a day into it," she said. "I'm scraping by. I do all my eating at home. I've gotten to be a much better cook." And in five years, what did she dream her site would become? "I think it would be great if we had a full-time writer or two and maybe a sales person."

She's a long way from that now. "You know, I wrote those stories for free," says Devlin, who supports himself as a computer programmer. "I got a falafel sandwich out of it. Lorraine bought me a falafel sandwich." The sort of wonk who reads city budgets, Devlin spotted the line item for vice mayor and last November FOIA'ed the Office of Management and Budget to find out where the money was going. It took a month of applying "elbow grease," as Devlin describes the FOIA process, but the city finally turned over the information.

The next decision was what to do with it. Swanson and Devlin discussed turning it over to the Tribune, but when the Trib began pounding the city over what it called a "stealth payroll" controlled by the City Council Finance Committee that was enriching the aldermen's friends and relatives, they decided to run their story themselves. "This was the other shoe, another account no one's looked at yet," Devlin told me. "We thought, 'We have to contribute to this dialogue.' It lit a fire under our butts."

As for Boylan, anyone thinking of launching a hyperlocal news site should ask him out for a cup of coffee first. In January Boylan, a freelance reporter, and Mike Fourcher, a political consultant, launched the Center Square Ledger to cover Lincoln Square, North Center, and Ravenswood Manor. The partnership didn't last; Fourcher relaunched the site as the Center Square Journal and Boylan is now competing against him with the Welles Park Bulldog.

Boylan supports himself by freelancing for publications other than his own. "The weekends are critical," he tells me. For example, two Saturdays ago he spent the day out in the neighborhoods covering stories for his site while his wife, Jane Rickard, took pictures for it at other events. In the evening they met up and drove to Milwaukee together to cover a Chicago Wolves game for the Tribune.

Support Independent Chicago Journalism: Join the Reader Revolution

We speak Chicago to Chicagoans, but we couldn’t do it without your help. Every dollar you give helps us continue to explore and report on the diverse happenings of our city. Our reporters scour Chicago in search of what’s new, what’s now, and what’s next. Stay connected to our city’s pulse by joining the Reader Revolution.

Are you in?

  Reader Revolutionary $35/month →  
  Rabble Rouser $25/month →  
  Reader Radical $15/month →  
  Reader Rebel  $5/month  → 

Not ready to commit? Send us what you can!

 One-time donation  →